It’s almost annual review season. As you prepare to meet with your three, four, or two dozen direct reports, keep a few things in mind. Your job is to make each meeting impactful, insightful, and inspiring. No small feat.
Name the meeting based on its purpose
Regardless of how your organization titles these meetings, when you email your direct reports to schedule their reviews, title the meeting: “Your 2026 Review and 2027 Goal-Setting Meeting.”
A review looks back at what has transpired. While goal-setting meeting looks forward, to how you and your colleague can strategize to help them hone their skills, improve their performance, and advance their career.
Retitling the meeting isn’t a semantic difference. It reminds both you and your direct report of the meeting’s purpose and prompts you to prepare differently and approach the conversation with a different spirit.
Approach the meeting with the correct mindset
Preparing for performance reviews extends beyond reading assessments from people who submitted evaluations or shared feedback by email. It requires adopting the right frame of mind.
As a leader, you may have several reviews scheduled in one day, alongside competing priorities, unexpected challenges, and the inevitable demands of running a business. By the time you reach your final meeting, you may be tired or distracted. That’s no excuse for treating the conversation as just another item on your calendar.
Remember: While this may be one more meeting in your day, it may be the most important professional conversation of the year for the person sitting across from you.
Your body language, tone of voice, energy, and choice of words need to communicate that this meeting matters. Sit up straight. Maintain eye contact. Give the person your full attention. Listen carefully, acknowledge their accomplishments, and demonstrate that you are genuinely invested in their continued development.
Your tone will tell them how genuinely proud you are of their successes and how committed you are to helping them improve in the coming year.
Do your due diligence
If you are responsible for delivering feedback gathered from others, you owe it to yourself and your direct report to ask a few questions of the people who provided it.
No one should hear something in their annual review for the first time. The review should summarize feedback the individual has received throughout the year. There is little value in telling an employee in December that they underperformed on a project in May. That feedback, delivered months after the fact, does little to improve performance. Instead, it undermines trust in leadership and can leave employees feeling blindsided.
Before incorporating feedback into an annual review, ask the people who provided it:
- Was this feedback communicated in real time? What was the employee’s response when the feedback was originally delivered? If a manager admits they never shared their concerns with an employee, that’s a separate leadership issue worth addressing. Managers have a responsibility to deliver difficult feedback throughout the year, not save it for someone else’s annual review.
- Has this assessment been consistent throughout the year? Have you observed improvement or a decline in the employee’s skills over time? People often default to commenting on someone’s historical reputation rather than evaluating their current performance. Make sure the feedback reflects recent, observable behavior rather than assumptions carried over from years past.
- How does this feedback compare with last year’s assessment? Evaluating someone’s performance and planning for their growth requires recognizing trends from year to year. If the feedback is consistent with prior years, what steps did the employee take to improve? If they tried but haven’t progressed, what other actions could the employee or organization take to help them succeed?
If the feedback identifies a new area of development, investigate what has changed in the employee’s circumstances, responsibilities, or working environment that might explain the issue.
The answers to these questions will help you distinguish between recurring performance concerns, new challenges, and opportunities for development. More importantly, they’ll help you create a thoughtful, actionable plan for the year ahead.
Be transparent about compensation and focus on what’s next
If a bonus is part of the discussion, communicate the number early in the conversation. It’s likely one of the things the employee is most interested in hearing. Until they know what their bonus looks like, they may struggle to process the rest of the information.
Building up to the number isn’t helpful. It can feel like teasing or taunting, or worse, setting someone up for a letdown. The bonus provides important context for the feedback that follows. It shouldn’t necessarily be the first words out of your mouth, but it should be the last sentence of your introduction.
For an employee who has had a strong year, you might say: “Your performance this year has been excellent. Your contributions have made a meaningful difference to the team, and the feedback from colleagues and clients reflects that. We’re pleased to share that your bonus reflects those accomplishments.”
For an employee who has faced challenges, you might say: “You’ve had several successes this year, and we’ve also discussed areas where your performance needs improvement. We’ll continue to work together to strengthen those skills and provide the support you need. In the meantime, your bonus is at the lower end of the range we’ve discussed.”
Make the review a roadmap for what’s next
Even when delivering difficult news, the overall meeting can be positive if you focus on the path forward rather than the path completed.
An annual review should never feel like a verdict on someone’s past performance. It should be an opportunity to recognize contributions, address challenges honestly, establish expectations, and create a plan for continued growth.
As a leader, your responsibility isn’t simply to evaluate the year that has passed. It’s to help your people make the next year better.
Originally published on Inc.com